Birth Trauma Law

Understanding the Apgar Score: A Guide for Families Dealing with Birth Trauma

As you cradle your newborn for the first time, the medical team is already assessing your baby’s health. Within minutes, they perform the Apgar score—a quick test that checks heart rate, breathing, muscle tone, reflexes and skin colour. It’s a routine procedure that you may not even notice in those emotional first moments. However, a low Apgar score can signal health concerns that require immediate attention.


Some issues flagged by the score can be resolved quickly, while others may indicate more serious conditions requiring further tests or treatment. If these early signs are missed, the consequences can be long-lasting. Knowing your legal rights in such cases is crucial and Birth Trauma Law is here to guide and support you.


Who Created the Apgar Score?


The Apgar scoring system was developed by Dr. Virginia Apgar in 1953. At the time, she was serving as the Director of Obstetric Anaesthesia at Presbyterian Hospital, where there were no formal protocols for providing medical intervention to infants experiencing respiratory distress or other complications shortly after birth.


Dr. Apgar created the scoring system in response to a student's question about what doctors should look for when performing a newborn's visual exam. After presenting it to her colleagues at a national anaesthesiology meeting, the score was published and soon became a widely-used tool in healthcare for identifying infants in need of urgent care.


What Is the Apgar Score?


The Apgar score is a non-invasive test performed at one and five minutes after birth to evaluate a newborn's health. It assesses five areas—appearance, pulse, grimace, activity and respiration—forming the acronym APGAR. Each area is scored from 0 to 2, with a total possible score of 10. A higher score indicates better health, while a low score suggests the need for immediate medical attention.


The Five Components of the Apgar Score


  • Appearance (Skin Colour):
    • 0 Points = Bluish-grey or pale all over
    • 1 Point = Normal colour, but hands and feet are bluish
    • 2 Points = Pink all over
  • Pulse (Heart Rate):
    • 0 Points = No pulse
    • 1 Point = Pulse below 100 beats per minute
    • 2 Points = Pulse above 100 beats per minute
  • Grimace (Reflex Response):
    • 0 Points = No response to stimulation
    • 1 Point = Grimace with stimulation
    • 2 Points = Pulls away, sneezes, coughs, or cries
  • Activity (Muscle Tone):
    • 0 Points = No movement or “floppy” tone
    • 1 Point = Flexed arms and legs, little movement
    • 2 Points = Active, spontaneous movement
  • Respiration (Breathing Effort):
    • 0 Points = No breathing
    • 1 Point = Slow or irregular breathing, weak crying
    • 2 Points = Good crying and normal breathing effort

A score of 7 or higher is reassuring. A lower score may indicate that the baby needs immediate medical help. 


What Happens When a Baby Has a Low Apgar Score?

A low Apgar score, typically 6 or below, can indicate complications such as poor heart rate, weak breathing, or lack of muscle tone. In these cases, medical professionals must act quickly, offering treatments like oxygen, suctioning airways, or administering medications. In some instances, delaying cord clamping can help increase blood flow.


If your baby had a low Apgar score and suffered complications, it’s vital to determine whether the necessary interventions were made in time. Delayed treatment can lead to permanent damage and in some cases, medical negligence may be involved. Read more about negligent management of pregnancy to understand your rights in such scenarios.


The Impact of the Apgar Score


The Apgar score helps identify infants at risk. Babies scoring between 0 and 2 face a much higher risk of death, with Dr. Apgar’s research showing a 14% mortality rate in this group. In contrast, babies scoring 8 to 10 have a much lower risk, with a mortality rate of only 0.13%. These numbers show how important it is to give immediate care to low-scoring infants.


In 2022, the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) reported that certain babies were more likely to have Apgar scores below 7. These include:


  • Low birthweight babies (8.1%)
  • Pre-term babies (8.1%)
  • Babies in breech presentation (5.6%)

Babies with scores below 7 often needed resuscitation and were more likely to be admitted to a special care nursery or neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). This highlights the need for extra care for infants with low scores.


What Causes a Low Apgar Score?


Several factors can contribute to a low Apgar score, including:


  • Oxygen Deprivation: A lack of oxygen to the brain can cause significant brain damage.
  • Hypoxic Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE): This condition results from oxygen deprivation, leading to brain cell damage. In some cases, infant cooling is used as a treatment to limit the damage.
  • Cerebral Palsy: This can be caused by congenital conditions, insufficient oxygen flow during birth, or genetic factors.

Low Apgar scores are also commonly associated with difficult births, such as high-risk pregnancies, premature deliveries, or prolonged labour. Early medical intervention in these situations can significantly improve outcomes.


Could a Low Apgar Score Be an Indicator of Medical Negligence?


While a low Apgar score doesn’t always mean medical negligence occurred, it could be a sign of poor medical decisions. If your baby’s score didn’t improve between the 1-minute and 5-minute marks and they suffered lasting injuries, negligence may have played a role. You may be entitled to birth trauma compensation in such cases.


How We Can Help You


At Birth Trauma Law, we specialise in helping families affected by birth injuries, especially in cases involving medical negligence. Our experienced team works closely with medical experts to ensure that families receive the justice and compensation they deserve. 


If your child’s low Apgar score and related injuries could have been prevented, contact us for a free consultation. We are relentless in seeking justice for families. For more information, check our FAQs.


Frequently Asked Questions


What does a low Apgar score mean for my child’s future?


A low Apgar score doesn’t always indicate long-term problems but if it remains low, it could suggest more serious issues. Monitor your child’s development closely and seek medical advice if needed. If you believe the low score is linked to negligent management of pregnancy, you may have grounds for a claim.


Can a low Apgar score be a sign of medical negligence?


Yes it can. If medical staff failed to act promptly when a low Apgar score was noted, it could indicate negligence. Our team at Birth Trauma Law can help determine if this was the case for your child. Learn more about birth trauma compensation and how we can support your case.


How do I prove negligence during pregnancy?


Proving negligence requires medical records, expert testimony and a thorough review of the care you received. For instance, failing to diagnose conditions like failure to diagnose in utero can be strong evidence of negligence. Contact a birth trauma lawyer for guidance.


Can birth-related negligence lead to psychological conditions?


Yes, medical negligence during pregnancy or childbirth can contribute to psychological conditions like postnatal depression or anxiety disorders. If you’re experiencing symptoms, it’s important to seek both medical and legal help.


What are postpartum birth trauma disorders?


Postpartum birth trauma disorders are psychological or physical conditions that arise after childbirth due to complications or negligence. Learn more about postpartum birth trauma disorders and how they may impact you or your baby.


Leave a Comment: